S&P 500: buy and hold, the 200-day average, 60/40 and a systematic strategy compared

$10,000 put into the S&P 500 in Aug 2002 became $133,400 by Jul 2026 with buy and hold, $95,500 with the 200-day average, $73,700 in a 60/40 portfolio and $159,000 with the InvestWealth System. The worst falls on the way: −54.6%, −24.4%, −30.5% and −28.6%.

Same data, same dates and same costs for all four. The first three are textbook approaches, described in full below. The fourth is ours: its results are shown, its method is not published.

All four, Aug 2002 to Jul 2026

growth of $10,000 · dividends reinvested · after costs
ApproachReturn a year$10,000 becameWorst fallfrom, toSwings a year
InvestWealth System12.2%$159,000−28.6%Dec 2021 to Oct 202213.5%
Buy and hold11.4%$133,400−54.6%Oct 2007 to Mar 200917.4%
200-day average9.9%$95,500−24.4%Dec 2021 to Mar 202311.6%
60/408.7%$73,700−30.5%Oct 2007 to Mar 200910.3%

The InvestWealth System had the highest return of the four (12.2% a year) and the second-smallest worst fall (−28.6%). Buy and hold had the deepest fall, 60/40 had the lowest return.

Logarithmic scale: equal distances are equal percentage moves. The period starts in Aug 2002 because the bond fund used for 60/40 (TLT) starts then. "Swings a year" is the yearly volatility from weekly closes.

How each of the four works

Buy and hold

Buy a fund that holds the S&P 500 and never sell. Nothing to decide and almost nothing to pay. The whole fall of the market is yours: −54.6% from Oct 2007 to Mar 2009.

The 200-day average

The best-known textbook timing method. On the last trading day of each month, compare the close with the average of the last 200 daily closes. Above the average: hold the S&P 500 for the next month. Below it: hold 3-month Treasury bills. It trades at that close. It steps aside in long declines such as 2008 and comes back late after sharp falls such as 2020, which is where it loses ground.

60/40

60% in the S&P 500 and 40% in long-term US Treasuries (the fund TLT), set back to 60/40 at each month-end. The bonds cushioned 2008. In 2022 they fell together with stocks: the mix lost 23.3% that year, the S&P 500 18.2%. A mix with shorter-term bonds would have moved less in both directions.

The InvestWealth System

Our systematic strategy for the S&P 500. It is reviewed once a month and is either invested in the S&P 500 or steps aside into defensive assets. The method itself is not published. What we publish is the result, on the S&P 500 page and in the free Research Terminal, with the same curve as in this comparison.

The longer record, Dec 1993 to Jul 2026

without 60/40: its bond fund did not exist yet
ApproachReturn a year$10,000 becameWorst fallfrom, toSwings a year
InvestWealth System12.1%$421,500−28.6%Dec 2021 to Oct 202213.2%
Buy and hold10.8%$286,200−54.6%Oct 2007 to Mar 200917.3%
200-day average10.5%$263,900−24.4%Dec 2021 to Mar 202312.1%

The InvestWealth System had the highest return of the three (12.1% a year) and the second-smallest worst fall (−28.6%). This period includes the fall of 2000 to 2002, which the first table does not.

Every calendar year

The years show where each approach earns its keep and where it costs. In 2008 buy and hold lost 36.8%, 60/40 lost 13.4%, the 200-day average made 1.6% and the InvestWealth System made 4.5%. In 2022 all four lost: 18.2%, 23.3%, 20.5% and 22.4%.

YearBuy and holdB&H200-day average200-day60/4060/40IW SystemIW
2026 to 31 Jul+10.1%−0.3%+4.7%+8.8%
2025+17.7%+12.3%+12.4%+14.3%
2024+24.9%+24.9%+10.7%+26.6%
2023+26.2%+9.3%+16.4%+26.2%
2022−18.2%−20.5%−23.3%−22.4%
2021+28.7%+28.7%+14.6%+28.6%
2020+18.3%+14.5%+19.8%+16.1%
2019+31.2%+10.3%+24.9%+20.2%
2018−4.6%−6.4%−2.9%+7.3%
2017+21.7%+21.7%+16.6%+21.7%
2016+12.0%+10.4%+8.0%+26.2%
2015+1.2%−4.6%+0.6%−5.4%
2014+13.5%+13.5%+19.0%+15.6%
2013+32.3%+32.3%+12.1%+33.9%
2012+16.0%+16.0%+11.0%+14.8%
2011+1.9%−2.2%+14.9%−10.0%
2010+15.1%+8.9%+13.8%+18.5%
2009+26.4%+22.5%+5.1%+4.3%
2008−36.8%+1.6%−13.4%+4.5%
2007+5.1%+5.0%+7.5%+5.0%
2006+15.8%+15.8%+9.7%+15.8%
2005+4.8%+4.8%+6.6%+4.8%
2004+10.7%+10.7%+10.0%+12.3%
2003+28.2%+22.9%+17.3%+19.5%
2002−21.6%−4.6%–+6.9%
2001−11.8%+3.5%–+3.5%
2000−9.7%−0.1%–−4.1%
1999+20.4%+13.3%–+17.0%
1998+28.7%+12.5%–+23.1%
1997+33.5%+33.5%–+13.4%
1996+22.5%+22.5%–+23.0%
1995+38.0%+38.0%–+34.0%
1994+0.4%−2.5%–−3.4%

Buy and hold, the 200-day average and 60/40: 31 December to 31 December, from daily closes. The InvestWealth System: from the last weekly close of one year to the last weekly close of the next, as on the S&P 500 page, so its years can differ by a few days of market movement.

See it for six core markets, free

The free Research Terminal shows the same comparison of our systematic strategy with buy and hold for six core markets: the S&P 500, the Nasdaq-100, gold, Bitcoin, crude oil and Nvidia.

Open a free account

Questions

Does the 200-day moving average beat buy and hold on the S&P 500?

From Dec 1993 to Jul 2026 it did not on return: the 200-day average returned 10.5% a year and buy and hold 10.8% a year. It did on the worst fall: −24.4% against −54.6%. Checked at each month-end close, with T-bills while out of the market, dividends reinvested, costs of 0.10% of each trade.

Is a 60/40 portfolio safer than the S&P 500?

Its worst fall was smaller: −30.5% against −54.6% for the S&P 500 between Aug 2002 and Jul 2026. The price was a lower return: 8.7% a year against 11.4%. Here 60/40 means 60% S&P 500 and 40% long-term US Treasuries, rebalanced monthly. In 2022 stocks and bonds fell together and this mix lost more than the S&P 500 alone.

How did the InvestWealth System do against these three?

From Aug 2002 to Jul 2026 the InvestWealth System returned 12.2% a year with a worst fall of −28.6%. Buy and hold: 11.4% and −54.6%. 200-day average: 9.9% and −24.4%. 60/40: 8.7% and −30.5%.

Are costs and dividends included?

Yes. All four are total return, with dividends and interest reinvested, and each trade costs 0.10% of the amount traded. Taxes are not included; an approach that trades realises gains earlier than buy and hold, which matters in a taxable account.

The S&P 500 page → · All 30 markets →

Notes: results before 16 October 2026 are backtested and hypothetical; the InvestWealth System was developed on historical data and its live record starts with the month-end of 30 October 2026. Public figures run about three months behind, here to Jul 2026. Costs of 0.10% of each trade are included, taxes are not. A different start date or a different bond fund in the 60/40 mix changes the figures. Educational research, not investment advice. Past returns do not guarantee future results. Disclaimer.

Free · one email a month

Get the month-end letter

  • 30 markets after every month-end: what rose, what fell, and where each stands this year.
  • The main asset classes in one table, from stocks and bonds to gold and Bitcoin.
Free · no card · instant access · login details by email