Bitcoin vs gold: returns, volatility and what each did in a crash

Bitcoin vs gold since 2011: return, volatility, Sharpe ratio, worst falls and recovery times, correlation, and what each did in every stock-market sell-off.

By Dr. Harry Hamann, MBA · published 15 Nov 2026 · updated 16 Nov 2026 · 13 min read

Bitcoin has returned far more than gold, and it has fallen far further. From August 2011 to November 2026 Bitcoin returned 77.5% a year and gold 5.1%; over the last ten years 58.0% against 12.3%. But Bitcoin swung about four times as hard, lost 85% at its worst, and fell in seven of eight stock-market sell-offs, while gold mostly held.

Bitcoin vs gold in one line: gold has been the steadier store of value and the better shelter when stocks fell; Bitcoin has been the far stronger grower, with falls of 50% to 85% on the way. The two have barely moved together, so the answer depends on what the holding is meant to do.

This guide compares the two on the same daily data, measured the same way: return over several windows, volatility, Sharpe ratio, every deep fall and how long it took to recover, how closely they move together, what each did in twelve stress episodes, and how they fared against inflation.

Bitcoin vs gold in numbers

BitcoinGoldS&P 500
Return per year, Aug 2011 – Nov 202677.5%5.1%15.2%
Return per year, last 10 years58.0%12.3%15.1%
Return per year, last 5 years1.2%15.8%11.5%
Return per year, last 3 years23.2%25.8%21.0%
Return, last 12 months−31.5%−7.4%+13.3%
Volatility per year, last 10 years68%17%18%
Sharpe ratio, last 10 years0.980.620.73
Worst fall since 2011−84.9% (Dec 2013 – Jan 2015)−44.4% (Aug 2011 – Dec 2015)−33.8% (Feb – Mar 2020)
Below the last high, 13 Nov 2026−45%−27%−3%

Source: daily closes from 18 Aug 2011 to 13 Nov 2026. Bitcoin in US$ (Bitstamp); gold in US$ per ounce (COMEX front-month future); S&P 500 with dividends reinvested. Volatility from daily returns, annualised (365 days a year for Bitcoin, which trades every day, and 252 for gold and stocks). Sharpe ratio: average return above 3-month US Treasury bills, divided by volatility.

Three things stand out:

  • The start date decides the winner. Since 2011 and over ten years, Bitcoin was far ahead. Over the last five years, which start close to Bitcoin's November 2021 high, gold returned 15.8% a year and Bitcoin 1.2%. Over three years gold was slightly ahead.
  • Bitcoin paid for its return with much larger swings. Over ten years its volatility was four times gold's, and its worst fall almost twice as deep.
  • Both are well below their highs. On 13 November 2026 Bitcoin was 45% below its October 2025 record and gold 27% below its January 2026 record.
Bitcoin vs gold since 2017 (growth of 100, log scale)
Growth of 100, buy & hold, total return, log scale. Data to Jul 2026.

The chart uses the market data of the Research Terminal, which start in August 2017 for Bitcoin; gold here is the GLD fund. On a log scale equal distances are equal percentage moves, so the much deeper dips of Bitcoin are easy to see.

$10,000 in Bitcoin vs $10,000 in gold

The same comparison as money. Each row starts on a different date and ends on 13 November 2026, buy and hold, no costs or taxes.

StartBitcoinGoldS&P 500
Aug 2011 (15 years)$62.6 million$21,400$86,000
Nov 2016 (10 years)$969,000$31,800$40,700
Nov 2021 (5 years)$10,600$20,800$17,200
Nov 2023 (3 years)$18,700$19,900$17,700
Nov 2025 (1 year)$6,800$9,300$11,300

The first row is extreme because Bitcoin cost $10.90 in August 2011: a young asset that rose about 6,000 times. That kind of start will not come again for Bitcoin, which is why the shorter windows matter more for anyone looking at the two today. In three of the five windows gold ended ahead.

Year by year

Bitcoin vs gold: calendar-year returns
Calendar-year total returns, buy & hold (last year to date)
Show the numbers as a table
YearBitcoinGoldS&P 500
2012+189.1%+7.0%+15.8%
2013+5,429%−28.2%+32.2%
2014−56.1%−1.5%+13.5%
2015+34.2%−10.4%+1.3%
2016+124.3%+8.5%+11.8%
2017+1,336%+13.6%+21.7%
2018−73.4%−2.1%−4.5%
2019+94.1%+18.9%+31.3%
2020+304.5%+24.7%+18.4%
2021+59.4%−3.5%+28.6%
2022−64.2%−0.1%−18.2%
2023+155.7%+13.4%+26.1%
2024+121.0%+27.5%+24.9%
2025−6.3%+64.4%+17.8%
2026 to 13 Nov−22.0%−10.5%+11.3%

Bitcoin beat gold in 10 of the 15 calendar years. Its worst year was 2018 (−73.4%), gold's 2013 (−28.2%). Bitcoin lost money in five years and gold in seven, but gold's losing years were small: apart from 2013, none was worse than −10.5%. In 2025 the order flipped: gold rose 64.4%, its best year in this data, while Bitcoin fell 6.3%.

Volatility: how much more Bitcoin swings

Volatility per year201320172020202220252026 to Nov
Bitcoin145%94%76%64%42%45%
Gold22%10%22%16%21%29%

Annualised volatility of daily returns in each calendar year.

Two trends meet in this table. Bitcoin's swings have shrunk a lot: from 145% a year in 2013 to 42% in 2025. Gold's have grown: 2026 has been its most volatile year in our data since 2011, at 29%. In 2017 Bitcoin swung more than nine times as hard as gold; in 2026 so far about one and a half times.

In day-to-day terms the gap is still large. Since 2011 Bitcoin moved more than 5% on about 50 days a year; gold on fewer than one. Bitcoin's worst month was −39.8%, gold's −12.1%. Our guide on the Sharpe ratio explains why volatility alone does not say whether a return was worth its risk.

Return for the risk: the Sharpe ratio

The Sharpe ratio divides the return above cash by the volatility, so it compares return for each unit of risk.

Sharpe ratioBitcoinGoldS&P 500
Aug 2011 – Nov 20261.100.280.82
Last 10 years0.980.620.73
Last 5 years0.200.660.50
Last 3 years0.580.961.05

Over the full period and over ten years, Bitcoin's return was large enough to beat gold even after its far larger swings. Over five and three years gold had the better ratio. A Sharpe ratio is backward-looking: it says how a past period paid, not how the next one will.

Worst falls and how long they took to recover

Bitcoin vs gold: fall from the previous high
Fall from the previous all-time high, buy & hold. Highs from before the chart starts count too, so a line can begin below 0%. Data to Jul 2026.
PeakLowFallBack at the old high
Bitcoin
Aug 2011Oct 2011−80.9%Aug 2012
Apr 2013Jul 2013−71.0%Nov 2013
Dec 2013Jan 2015−84.9%Feb 2017
Dec 2017Dec 2018−83.4%Nov 2020
Apr 2021Jul 2021−53.1%Oct 2021
Nov 2021Nov 2022−76.7%Mar 2024
Oct 2025Jun 2026−53.1%not yet
Gold
Aug 2011Dec 2015−44.4%Jul 2020
Aug 2020Nov 2022−21.2%Dec 2023
Jan 2026Nov 2026−26.9%not yet

Bitcoin: every fall of more than 50%; gold: every fall of more than 15%. Daily closes from 18 Aug 2011, which is after Bitcoin's June 2011 bubble peak. To 13 Nov 2026.

Bitcoin had seven falls of more than 50% in fifteen years; gold none. But look at the last column. Bitcoin's time underwater after its deepest falls was two to three years. Gold's was much longer: a buyer at the August 2011 high waited almost nine years, until July 2020, to be back at even, while Bitcoin rose many times over. Gold's falls are shallower and slower, and so are its recoveries. Our guide on max drawdown explains why depth and length both matter, and the drawdown recovery calculator shows the gain needed to get back: after −85% it is +567%.

Do Bitcoin and gold move together?

Hardly. The correlation of daily returns, where 1 means always moving together and 0 means no link, was 0.07 from 2011 to 2026. On weekly returns it was 0.09, on monthly returns −0.03.

Correlation of daily returns2011–20162017–20192020–20232024 – Nov 2026
Bitcoin with gold0.040.070.120.14
Bitcoin with S&P 5000.010.010.380.39
Gold with S&P 5000.01−0.130.120.15

Measured on the days both markets traded.

Measured over rolling twelve-month windows, the correlation of Bitcoin and gold never left a narrow band: between −0.13 (May 2022) and +0.29 (November 2020). The latest reading, for the year to 13 November 2026, was 0.24, near the top of that band.

Bitcoin vs gold: 36-month correlation of monthly returns
Below 0: the two move in opposite directions (the hedge works) · above 0: they move together · monthly total returns

The more important change is in the second row. Until 2019 Bitcoin moved independently of stocks as well. Since 2020 its correlation with the S&P 500 has been close to 0.4, as large investors and funds began to hold it next to their shares. Gold's link to stocks stayed low throughout. That difference shows up most clearly when stocks fall.

Which one held up in a crash?

EpisodeS&P 500BitcoinGold
China devaluation, 17 – 25 Aug 2015−11.2%−13.3%+1.8%
S&P 500 fall, May 2015 – Feb 2016−14.2%+60.8%+3.6%
Volatility shock, 26 Jan – 8 Feb 2018−10.2%−25.5%−2.6%
Q4 2018 sell-off, 20 Sep – 24 Dec−19.8%−37.8%+5.1%
Covid crash, 19 Feb – 23 Mar 2020−33.9%−32.3%−2.5%
Russia invades Ukraine, 23 Feb – 8 Mar 2022−1.3%+4.0%+7.0%
2022 bear market, 3 Jan – 12 Oct−25.4%−58.7%−6.8%
Terra/Luna collapse, 5 May – 18 Jun 2022−11.4%−48.1%−1.9%
FTX collapse, 4 – 21 Nov 2022+4.8%−25.5%+3.8%
US bank failures, 8 – 13 Mar 2023−3.4%+11.5%+5.4%
Yen carry unwind, 31 Jul – 5 Aug 2024−6.1%−16.4%+0.7%
Tariff sell-off, 19 Feb – 8 Apr 2025−18.9%−21.1%+1.8%

Price changes from close to close over each period; S&P 500 price index.

In the eight episodes in which the S&P 500 fell 10% or more, Bitcoin fell in seven, and by more than stocks in six. The exception was the slow stock-market fall of 2015–2016, when Bitcoin was still climbing out of its own crash and had almost no link to stocks. Gold fell in four of the eight, by 6.8% at most, and rose in the other four.

Two episodes went the other way. When Russia invaded Ukraine and when US banks failed in March 2023, Bitcoin rose along with gold. And in the two crashes that started inside crypto, Terra/Luna and FTX, Bitcoin fell hard while gold barely moved or rose. So far the "digital gold" label has not held in sell-offs: in the stock-market falls since 2015, Bitcoin behaved more like a risky asset than like a shelter. Our guide on protecting a portfolio from a crash compares gold, bonds and other hedges over a longer history, and gold vs bonds the two classic ones.

Bitcoin vs gold as an inflation hedge

The clearest test came in 2021 and 2022, when US consumer prices rose 7.0% and 6.5%, the fastest in forty years.

20212022
US inflation+7.0%+6.5%
Bitcoin+59.4%−64.2%
Gold−3.5%−0.1%
S&P 500+28.6%−18.2%

Neither kept pace with inflation in 2022. Gold roughly held its dollar value while prices rose, a loss of about 6% after inflation; Bitcoin lost almost two thirds. What hurt Bitcoin was less the inflation than the response to it: as interest rates rose, risky assets fell together.

Over the whole period, US inflation averaged 2.7% a year. Gold returned 5.1% a year, or about 2.4% a year after inflation, held back by its high starting point in August 2011. Bitcoin returned about 73% a year after inflation. Over long stretches gold has kept its buying power; over one or two years neither has been a reliable hedge.

Bitcoin priced in gold

Another way to compare the two is to ask how many ounces of gold one Bitcoin buys.

  • 18 Aug 2011: 0.006 ounces
  • Dec 2017 high: 13.9 ounces
  • Nov 2021 high: 35.1 ounces
  • 17 Dec 2024, the peak of this ratio: 39.9 ounces
  • 6 Oct 2025, Bitcoin's record in dollars: 31.4 ounces
  • 13 Nov 2026: 17.6 ounces

Measured in gold, Bitcoin peaked almost a year before its dollar record and was 56% below that peak in November 2026. Gold's strong 2025 meant that Bitcoin's last dollar high was not a high in gold terms.

Bitcoin and gold together

Because they have moved almost independently, a small Bitcoin share changes a gold holding more in return than in risk. The table shows a backtest of mixes of the two from November 2016, rebalanced every month.

Bitcoin shareReturn per yearVolatilityWorst fall
0% (gold only)12.8%14.8%−25.9%
5%16.2%14.9%−24.5%
10%19.5%16.0%−23.1%
20%25.8%20.3%−23.9%
50%42.1%39.8%−46.3%
100% (Bitcoin only)57.5%76.9%−76.2%

Hypothetical backtest, Nov 2016 – Nov 2026: month-end prices, rebalanced monthly, no costs or taxes. Month-end values miss falls within a month, so the worst falls are smaller than on daily closes.

90% gold and 10% Bitcoin vs gold alone (rebalanced monthly)
Growth of 100, log scale · total return, rebalanced monthly, no costs or taxes · data from 2017-08

Read this with care. These ten years include a period in which Bitcoin rose about 97 times, the kind of run that made any Bitcoin share look good. Over the last five years, when Bitcoin went almost nowhere, mixes with up to 20% Bitcoin returned about the same as gold alone (about 17% a year on month-end prices), and a 50% share returned less (14.2%) with almost twice the volatility. What the table does show is the mechanism: up to about 10%, Bitcoin's own falls were small next to the whole and were partly offset by gold. Above that, its swings took over. Our guide on Bitcoin in a portfolio works through sizing for an 80% fall.

Bitcoin vs gold: what is the difference?

  • History. Gold has been used as money and jewellery for thousands of years and is held by central banks. Bitcoin was launched in January 2009 and has been through about four full boom-and-bust cycles.
  • Supply. About 216,000 tonnes of gold have been mined (World Gold Council estimate), and mining adds roughly 1% to 2% a year. Bitcoin's supply is fixed at 21 million coins; just under 20 million exist, and new issuance halves about every four years, most recently in April 2024.
  • Size. At November 2026 prices, all the gold above ground was worth about $27 trillion and all Bitcoin about $1.4 trillion, roughly one twentieth.
  • Access and custody. Gold can be held as bars, coins or through funds such as GLD (since 2004). Bitcoin can be held in self-custody or, in the US, through spot ETFs (since January 2024). Our guide on how to buy and store crypto compares the routes.
  • What drives the price. Gold has tended to rise with fear, falling real interest rates and central-bank buying. Bitcoin has tended to rise and fall with the appetite for risk, and with flows into and out of crypto.

For silver as the other precious metal, see silver vs gold; for Bitcoin next to the two largest altcoins, Bitcoin vs Ethereum vs Solana. For each of the two against US stocks, see Bitcoin vs S&P 500 and gold vs S&P 500; for Bitcoin's worst single days, the biggest crypto crashes, ranked.

The short answer

On data to 13 November 2026, Bitcoin has been the much stronger grower and gold the much steadier holding. Over ten years Bitcoin returned 58.0% a year against 12.3%, with a better Sharpe ratio (0.98 against 0.62). Over five years gold was ahead, 15.8% against 1.2% a year. Bitcoin's falls went to −85% and came in every stock-market sell-off since 2018; gold's worst fall was −44%, slow and long, and it fell by no more than 6.8% in any of the eight stock-market falls since 2015. Their daily returns have been almost unrelated (correlation 0.07), which is why some investors hold both rather than choosing.

Bitcoin and gold are both among the six core markets of the free Research Terminal: their falls from the high, updated daily, in the Drawdowns tab, and how they move against stocks right now in the Correlations tab.

Educational research, not investment advice. Past returns do not guarantee future results. Backtests are hypothetical.

Frequently asked questions

Is Bitcoin better than gold?

It depends on the job. Over the ten years to November 2026 Bitcoin returned 58.0% a year and gold 12.3%, but Bitcoin was about four times as volatile and fell up to 85%. Gold fell no more than 6.8% in any of the eight S&P 500 falls of 10% or more since 2015, while Bitcoin fell in seven of them. Over the last five years gold returned more (15.8% against 1.2% a year). Educational information, not a recommendation.

Has Bitcoin outperformed gold over the last 10 years?

Yes. From November 2016 to November 2026, $10,000 in Bitcoin grew to about $969,000 and $10,000 in gold to about $31,800 (58.0% against 12.3% a year, buy and hold). Over the last five years the order was reversed: gold returned 15.8% a year and Bitcoin 1.2%. Past returns do not guarantee future results.

Is Bitcoin more volatile than gold?

Yes, much more. Over the ten years to November 2026 Bitcoin had a volatility of 68% a year against 17% for gold. Since 2011 Bitcoin moved more than 5% on about 50 days a year, gold on fewer than one. The gap has narrowed: in 2026 to November, Bitcoin was about 1.5 times as volatile as gold (45% against 29%).

Are Bitcoin and gold correlated?

Hardly. The correlation of their daily returns was 0.07 from 2011 to November 2026, and in rolling twelve-month windows it stayed between −0.13 and +0.29. Bitcoin has been more closely linked to stocks since 2020 (about 0.4 with the S&P 500).

Is Bitcoin digital gold or a safe haven?

Not in sell-offs so far. In the eight S&P 500 falls of 10% or more since 2015, Bitcoin fell in seven, by up to 58.7% (2022), and by more than stocks in six. Gold fell in four of them and never by more than 6.8%. Bitcoin did rise with gold after the invasion of Ukraine and during the US bank failures of March 2023.

Which is a better inflation hedge, Bitcoin or gold?

In the inflation of 2021 and 2022, gold held its dollar value (−3.5% and −0.1%) while US prices rose 7.0% and 6.5%. Bitcoin rose 59.4% in 2021 and fell 64.2% in 2022. Over long periods gold has kept its buying power; over one or two years neither has been reliable.

How many ounces of gold is one Bitcoin worth?

On 13 November 2026 one Bitcoin bought about 17.6 ounces of gold. The ratio peaked at 39.9 ounces on 17 December 2024 and stood at 0.006 ounces in August 2011.

What were the worst falls of Bitcoin and gold?

Bitcoin fell 84.9% from December 2013 to January 2015 and 83.4% from December 2017 to December 2018, recovering within about two to three years each time. Gold fell 44.4% from August 2011 to December 2015 and did not regain its 2011 high until July 2020, almost nine years later.

Should I buy Bitcoin or gold?

No guide can answer that for you; it depends on how large a fall you can sit through and what the holding is meant to do. The record shows the trade-off: much higher growth with falls of 50% to 85% for Bitcoin, lower growth with smaller falls and a better record in stock-market sell-offs for gold. Educational information, not a recommendation.

Cite or link this guide

Writing about this topic? You are welcome to quote the figures with a link to this page. Click a box to copy.

Citation (APA)

Hamann, H. (2026). Bitcoin vs gold: returns, volatility and what each did in a crash. InvestWealth.com. https://www.investwealth.com/learn/guides/bitcoin-vs-gold

Link (HTML)

<a href="https://www.investwealth.com/learn/guides/bitcoin-vs-gold">Bitcoin vs gold: returns, volatility and what each did in a crash</a> (InvestWealth.com)
Free Research Terminal

Bitcoin and gold side by side, in live numbers

  • Strategies: Bitcoin with a rule-based strategy against buy & hold, with equity curve and worst fall
  • Drawdowns: its four deepest falls and the days each took to recover
  • Correlations: how Bitcoin moves against stocks and gold on current data
Free · no card · instant access · login details by email
Or run the free Portfolio Crash Test →

Related guides

Educational research, not investment advice. Disclaimer.