Bitcoin vs S&P 500: returns, risk and what Bitcoin did when stocks fell

Bitcoin vs the S&P 500 since 2011: return, volatility, Sharpe ratio, worst falls and time underwater, correlation in sell-offs, and a 1–5% Bitcoin share tested.

By Dr. Harry Hamann, MBA · published 15 Nov 2026 · updated 16 Nov 2026 · 13 min read

Bitcoin has returned far more than the S&P 500 since 2011, with much larger falls. From August 2011 to November 2026 Bitcoin returned 77.5% a year and the S&P 500 15.2% with dividends; over ten years 58.0% against 15.1%. But Bitcoin swung about four times as hard, fell 85% at its worst, and since 2020 has mostly fallen when stocks fell.

Bitcoin vs the S&P 500 in one line: Bitcoin has been the much stronger grower with falls of 50% to 85% on the way; the S&P 500 has been the steadier one. Until 2019 the two moved independently. Since 2020 Bitcoin has behaved like a more volatile version of the stock market, so it has diversified a stock portfolio less than its history suggests.

This guide compares the two on the same daily data, measured the same way: return over several windows, volatility, Sharpe ratio, every deep fall and the time underwater, how closely they move together and whether Bitcoin fell with stocks in sell-offs, the best and worst years, and what a small Bitcoin share added to an S&P 500 holding in a hypothetical backtest.

Bitcoin vs the S&P 500 in numbers

BitcoinS&P 500
Return per year, Aug 2011 – Nov 202677.5%15.2%
Return per year, last 10 years58.0%15.1%
Return per year, last 5 years1.2%11.5%
Return per year, last 3 years23.2%21.0%
Return, last 12 months−31.5%+13.3%
Volatility per year, last 10 years68%18%
Sharpe ratio, last 10 years0.980.73
Worst fall since 2011−84.9% (Dec 2013 – Jan 2015)−33.8% (Feb – Mar 2020)
Below the last high, 13 Nov 2026−45%−3%

Source: daily closes from 18 Aug 2011 to 13 Nov 2026. Bitcoin in US$ (Bitstamp); S&P 500 with dividends reinvested. Volatility from daily returns, annualised (365 days a year for Bitcoin, which trades every day, and 252 for stocks). Sharpe ratio: average return above 3-month US Treasury bills, divided by volatility.

Three things stand out:

  • The start date decides the gap. Since 2011 and over ten years Bitcoin was far ahead. Over the last five years, which start close to Bitcoin's November 2021 high, the S&P 500 returned 11.5% a year and Bitcoin 1.2%. Over three years they were close.
  • Bitcoin paid for its return with much larger swings. Over ten years its volatility was almost four times that of the S&P 500, and its worst fall two and a half times as deep.
  • They are in very different places today. On 13 November 2026 the S&P 500 was 3% below its October 2026 record; Bitcoin was 45% below its October 2025 record.
Bitcoin vs the S&P 500 since 2017 (growth of 100, log scale)
Growth of 100, buy & hold, total return, log scale. Data to Jul 2026.

The chart uses the market data of the Research Terminal, which start in August 2017 for Bitcoin. On a log scale equal distances are equal percentage moves, so Bitcoin's deeper dips are easy to see.

$10,000 in Bitcoin vs $10,000 in the S&P 500

The same comparison as money. Each row starts on a different date and ends on 13 November 2026, buy and hold, dividends reinvested, no costs or taxes.

StartBitcoinS&P 500
Aug 2011 (15 years)$62.6 million$86,000
Nov 2016 (10 years)$969,000$40,700
Nov 2021 (5 years)$10,600$17,200
Nov 2023 (3 years)$18,700$17,700
Nov 2025 (1 year)$6,800$11,300

The first row is extreme because Bitcoin cost $10.90 in August 2011, when it was a tiny, young asset. A rise of about 6,000 times will not repeat from today's size, so the shorter windows say more about the two as they are now. In two of the five windows the S&P 500 ended ahead.

Best and worst years

Bitcoin vs the S&P 500: calendar-year returns
Calendar-year total returns, buy & hold (last year to date)
Show the numbers as a table
YearBitcoinS&P 500
2012+189.1%+15.8%
2013+5,429%+32.2%
2014−56.1%+13.5%
2015+34.2%+1.3%
2016+124.3%+11.8%
2017+1,336%+21.7%
2018−73.4%−4.5%
2019+94.1%+31.3%
2020+304.5%+18.4%
2021+59.4%+28.6%
2022−64.2%−18.2%
2023+155.7%+26.1%
2024+121.0%+24.9%
2025−6.3%+17.8%
2026 to 13 Nov−22.0%+11.3%

Bitcoin beat the S&P 500 in 10 of the 15 calendar years, and the five years it lost were exactly the five years in which Bitcoin fell. Its best year was 2013 (+5,429%), its worst 2018 (−73.4%). The S&P 500's best year was also 2013 (+32.2%) and its worst 2022 (−18.2%); it lost money in only two years, 2018 and 2022, and in both Bitcoin lost far more. The pattern is plain: in good years Bitcoin won by a wide margin; in bad years it lost by a wide margin.

Volatility: how much more Bitcoin swings

Volatility per year201320172020202220252026 to Nov
Bitcoin145%94%76%64%42%45%
S&P 50011%7%34%24%19%14%

Annualised volatility of daily returns in each calendar year.

The ratio has fallen a long way. In 2013 and 2017 Bitcoin swung 13 to 14 times as hard as the S&P 500. In 2020 and 2025 it was about 2.2 times; in 2026 so far about three times. Bitcoin has become calmer, but it is still in a different class: since 2011 it moved more than 5% on about 50 days a year, the S&P 500 on fewer than one. Bitcoin's worst month was −39.8%, the S&P 500's −12.3%.

Return for the risk: the Sharpe ratio

The Sharpe ratio divides the return above cash by the volatility, so it compares return for each unit of risk.

Sharpe ratioBitcoinS&P 500
Aug 2011 – Nov 20261.100.82
Last 10 years0.980.73
Last 5 years0.200.50
Last 3 years0.581.05

Over the full period and over ten years, Bitcoin's return was large enough to beat the S&P 500 even after its far larger swings. Over five and three years the S&P 500 had the better ratio. A Sharpe ratio describes how a past period paid; it says nothing about the next one. Our guide on the Sharpe ratio explains how to read it.

Worst falls and time underwater

Bitcoin vs the S&P 500: fall from the previous high
Fall from the previous all-time high, buy & hold. Highs from before the chart starts count too, so a line can begin below 0%. Data to Jul 2026.
PeakLowFallBack at the old highTime underwater
Bitcoin
Aug 2011Oct 2011−80.9%Aug 20121.0 years
Apr 2013Jul 2013−71.0%Nov 20130.6 years
Dec 2013Jan 2015−84.9%Feb 20173.2 years
Dec 2017Dec 2018−83.4%Nov 20203.0 years
Apr 2021Jul 2021−53.1%Oct 20210.5 years
Nov 2021Nov 2022−76.7%Mar 20242.3 years
Oct 2025Jun 2026−53.1%not yet1.1 years so far
S&P 500
Jul 2015Feb 2016−13.0%Apr 20160.8 years
Jan 2018Feb 2018−10.1%Aug 20180.5 years
Sep 2018Dec 2018−19.4%Apr 20190.6 years
Feb 2020Mar 2020−33.8%Aug 20200.5 years
Jan 2022Oct 2022−24.5%Dec 20231.9 years
Feb 2025Apr 2025−18.8%Jun 20250.4 years

Bitcoin: every fall of more than 50%; S&P 500: every fall of more than 10%, with dividends. Daily closes from 18 Aug 2011, to 13 Nov 2026. Time underwater: from the peak until the old high was back.

Bitcoin had seven falls of more than 50% in fifteen years; the S&P 500 none deeper than 34%. Bitcoin's longest time underwater was 3.2 years, the S&P 500's 1.9 years (2022–2023). Measured differently: on 75% of all days since 2011, Bitcoin was at least 20% below its previous high; the S&P 500 was that far down on 1% of days. Bitcoin's recoveries were fast for their depth, but a holder had to sit through losses that most people do not. Our guide on max drawdown explains why depth and length both matter, and the drawdown recovery calculator shows the gain needed to get back: after −85% it is +567%.

Does Bitcoin move with stocks?

It did not, and now it does. The correlation of daily returns, where 1 means always moving together and 0 means no link, was close to zero for Bitcoin's first eight years in our data and has been around 0.4 since 2020.

Correlation of Bitcoin with the S&P 5002011–20162017–20192020–20232024 – Nov 2026
Daily returns0.010.010.380.39

Measured on the days both markets traded; Bitcoin's weekend moves count towards the next stock-market day.

By calendar year, the highest reading was 2022 (0.56), the year in which both fell as interest rates rose. 2025 (0.43) and 2026 so far (0.47) were also high. On monthly returns since 2020 the correlation was 0.53. A rough way to read the size of the link: since 2020, for each 1% move of the S&P 500 in a day, Bitcoin moved on average about 1.15% in the same direction, on top of its own large swings.

Bitcoin vs the S&P 500: 36-month correlation of monthly returns
Bitcoin vs the S&P 500: 36-month correlation of monthly returns
Below 0: the two move in opposite directions (the hedge works) · above 0: they move together · monthly total returns

Over rolling 36-month windows of monthly returns, the correlation was close to zero at the end of 2019 (0.01) and peaked at 0.60 in February 2023. It was 0.49 in November 2026. The data cannot say why the link appeared. It came in 2020, four years before the US Securities and Exchange Commission approved the first spot Bitcoin exchange-traded products on 10 January 2024 (SEC statement), so easier access through funds is at most part of the story. Since 2020 Bitcoin has risen and fallen with the appetite for risk in general.

Did Bitcoin fall when stocks fell?

Since 2020, mostly yes. The table counts the days on which the S&P 500 fell 2% or more, and what Bitcoin did on the same days.

S&P 500 down dayDaysBitcoin fell onBitcoin, median move
2% or more, Aug 2011 – 20195244% of them0.0%
2% or more, 2020 – Nov 20266775% of them−3.0%
3% or more, Aug 2011 – 2019104 of them+0.7%
3% or more, 2020 – Nov 20262819 of them−4.6%

Before 2020 a bad day for stocks told you nothing about Bitcoin. Since 2020 Bitcoin fell on three out of four such days, and on the worst ones it fell further than stocks.

The same shows up in every larger sell-off:

EpisodeS&P 500Bitcoin
China devaluation, 17 – 25 Aug 2015−11.2%−13.3%
S&P 500 fall, May 2015 – Feb 2016−14.2%+60.8%
Volatility shock, 26 Jan – 8 Feb 2018−10.2%−25.5%
Q4 2018 sell-off, 20 Sep – 24 Dec−19.8%−37.8%
Covid crash, 19 Feb – 23 Mar 2020−33.9%−32.3%
2022 bear market, 3 Jan – 12 Oct−25.4%−58.7%
Yen carry unwind, 31 Jul – 5 Aug 2024−6.1%−16.4%
Tariff sell-off, 19 Feb – 8 Apr 2025−18.9%−21.1%

Price changes from close to close over each period; S&P 500 price index.

In the seven S&P 500 falls of 10% or more since 2015, Bitcoin fell in six, and by more than stocks in five. The exception was the slow fall of 2015–2016, when Bitcoin was climbing out of its own crash and had no link to stocks. So far Bitcoin has not been a shelter when stocks fall. Our guide on Bitcoin vs gold shows that gold held up much better in the same episodes, and protecting a portfolio from a crash compares the classic hedges over a longer history.

After inflation

US consumer prices rose 2.7% a year from August 2011 to October 2026. After inflation, the S&P 500 returned about 12.2% a year and Bitcoin about 72.9%. In 2022, when US inflation was 6.5%, both lost money in real terms: the S&P 500 about 23% and Bitcoin about two thirds. As interest rates rose that year, the two fell together, which is when the correlation peaked.

A small Bitcoin share in an S&P 500 holding

What did a small Bitcoin share do to a stock holding? The table shows a hypothetical backtest: the S&P 500 with dividends, plus 1% to 5% in Bitcoin, rebalanced back to the target every month.

Bitcoin shareReturn per yearVolatilityWorst fallSharpe ratio2022
0% (S&P 500 only)15.0%15.3%−23.9%0.82−18.2%
1%15.6%15.5%−24.2%0.86−18.7%
2%16.2%15.6%−24.6%0.88−19.3%
3%16.9%15.8%−25.0%0.91−19.8%
5%18.1%16.3%−25.7%0.96−20.9%

Hypothetical backtest, Nov 2016 – Nov 2026: month-end prices, rebalanced monthly, no costs or taxes. Month-end values miss falls within a month, so the worst falls are smaller than on daily closes.

95% S&P 500 and 5% Bitcoin vs the S&P 500 alone (rebalanced monthly)
Growth of 100, log scale · total return, rebalanced monthly, no costs or taxes · data from 2017-08

Read this with care. These ten years include a period in which Bitcoin rose about 97 times. Each 1% of Bitcoin added about 0.6 percentage points a year of return, and a little volatility. Over the last five years, when Bitcoin went almost nowhere, the same shares made almost no difference: 12.2% a year with no Bitcoin, 12.3% with 5%, and a slightly lower Sharpe ratio. In 2022 each 1% of Bitcoin made the year's loss about half a percentage point worse.

Two things are clear from the numbers. First, at 1% to 5% the share was too small to change the worst falls much: they were set by the stock market. Second, the rebalancing did a lot of the work. Without it, a 5% Bitcoin share bought in November 2016 would have grown to 71% of the whole at its peak and still been 55% in November 2026: a portfolio that started as a stock holding would have ended mostly in Bitcoin. Our guide on Bitcoin in a portfolio works through sizing for an 80% fall, inside a mix of stocks and bonds.

Bitcoin vs the S&P 500: what is the difference?

  • What you own. The S&P 500 is a share in 500 large US companies, with their earnings and dividends. Bitcoin pays no income; its price depends only on what the next buyer will pay.
  • History. The S&P 500 has daily data back to 1927 and has been through the Great Depression, wars and many recessions. Bitcoin is much younger: our daily data start in August 2011, and in that time it has fallen more than 50% seven times.
  • Trading hours. Stocks trade on weekdays; Bitcoin trades every day, all day. A weekend fall in Bitcoin shows up only on Monday in a comparison with stocks.
  • Access. Both can be held through ETFs in an ordinary brokerage account in the US: S&P 500 funds since the 1990s, spot Bitcoin funds since January 2024 (see the SEC statement above). Bitcoin can also be held in self-custody; see how to buy and store crypto.

For the S&P 500 on its own, see S&P 500 historical returns; for Bitcoin next to the two largest altcoins, Bitcoin vs Ethereum vs Solana. For the S&P 500 against gold, bonds and the Dow, see gold vs S&P 500, stocks vs bonds and S&P 500 vs Dow Jones; for Bitcoin's worst single days, the biggest crypto crashes, ranked.

The short answer

On data to 13 November 2026, Bitcoin has been the much stronger grower and the S&P 500 the much steadier holding. Over ten years Bitcoin returned 58.0% a year against 15.1%, with a better Sharpe ratio (0.98 against 0.73). Over five years the S&P 500 was well ahead, 11.5% against 1.2% a year. Bitcoin's falls went to −85% and kept it underwater for up to three years; the S&P 500's worst fall was −34%. And since 2020 Bitcoin has mostly fallen when stocks fell, so it has not been the diversifier its early history suggested.

Bitcoin and the S&P 500 are both among the six core markets of the free Research Terminal: their falls from the high, updated daily, in the Drawdowns tab, and how they move together right now in the Correlations tab.

Educational research, not investment advice. Past returns do not guarantee future results. Backtests are hypothetical.

Frequently asked questions

Has Bitcoin outperformed the S&P 500?

Over long windows, yes. From November 2016 to November 2026 Bitcoin returned 58.0% a year and the S&P 500 15.1% with dividends; $10,000 grew to about $969,000 against $40,700. Over the last five years the order was reversed: the S&P 500 returned 11.5% a year and Bitcoin 1.2%. Past returns do not guarantee future results.

Is Bitcoin riskier than the S&P 500?

Yes, by every measure in our data. Over the ten years to November 2026 Bitcoin had a volatility of 68% a year against 18%. Its worst fall since 2011 was −84.9%, the S&P 500’s −33.8%. Bitcoin has had seven falls of more than 50% since 2011 and spent 75% of all days at least 20% below its previous high.

Is Bitcoin correlated with the S&P 500?

Since 2020, yes. The correlation of daily returns was 0.01 from 2011 to 2019 and about 0.38 to 0.39 since 2020, with a high of 0.56 in 2022. On monthly returns since 2020 it was 0.53. Before 2020 the two moved almost independently.

Does Bitcoin fall when stocks fall?

Mostly, since 2020. On the 67 days since 2020 on which the S&P 500 fell 2% or more, Bitcoin fell on 75% of them, by a median 3.0%. In the seven S&P 500 falls of 10% or more since 2015, Bitcoin fell in six, by up to 58.7% in 2022.

What were the best and worst years of Bitcoin and the S&P 500?

Bitcoin’s best calendar year was 2013 (+5,429%) and its worst 2018 (−73.4%). The S&P 500’s best year since 2012 was also 2013 (+32.2%) and its worst 2022 (−18.2%). Bitcoin beat the S&P 500 in 10 of the 15 years from 2012 to 2026; the five years it lost were the years it fell.

How much does a 5% Bitcoin share change an S&P 500 portfolio?

In a hypothetical backtest from November 2016 to November 2026, rebalanced monthly, 5% Bitcoin raised the return from 15.0% to 18.1% a year and the volatility from 15.3% to 16.3%; the worst month-end fall went from −23.9% to −25.7%. Over the last five years the same share made almost no difference (12.2% against 12.3% a year). Hypothetical, not a recommendation.

How long did Bitcoin and the S&P 500 take to recover from their worst falls?

Bitcoin was back at its old high 3.2 years after the December 2013 peak and 3.0 years after the December 2017 peak. The S&P 500’s longest time underwater since 2011 was 1.9 years, from January 2022 to December 2023, with dividends.

Should I buy Bitcoin or the S&P 500?

No guide can answer that for you; it depends on how large a fall you can sit through and what the money is for. The record shows the trade-off: much higher growth with falls of 50% to 85% for Bitcoin, lower growth with smaller falls for the S&P 500, and since 2020 the two have tended to fall together. Educational information, not a recommendation.

Cite or link this guide

Writing about this topic? You are welcome to quote the figures with a link to this page. Click a box to copy.

Citation (APA)

Hamann, H. (2026). Bitcoin vs S&P 500: returns, risk and what Bitcoin did when stocks fell. InvestWealth.com. https://www.investwealth.com/learn/guides/bitcoin-vs-sp500

Link (HTML)

<a href="https://www.investwealth.com/learn/guides/bitcoin-vs-sp500">Bitcoin vs S&P 500: returns, risk and what Bitcoin did when stocks fell</a> (InvestWealth.com)
Free Research Terminal

Bitcoin and the S&P 500 side by side, in live numbers

  • Strategies: Bitcoin with a rule-based strategy against buy & hold, with equity curve and worst fall
  • Drawdowns: its four deepest falls and the days each took to recover
  • Correlations: how Bitcoin moves against stocks and gold on current data
Free · no card · instant access · login details by email
Or run the free Portfolio Crash Test →

Related guides

Educational research, not investment advice. Disclaimer.