Gold vs S&P 500: returns since 1968, decade by decade

Gold vs the S&P 500 since 1968: returns by decade and after inflation, worst falls and time underwater, correlation, and what gold did in every stock-market crash.

By Dr. Harry Hamann, MBA · published 15 Nov 2026 · updated 16 Nov 2026 · 13 min read

Over the long run the S&P 500 has beaten gold, but not in every decade. From January 1968 to November 2026 the S&P 500 with dividends returned 10.6% a year and gold 8.3%. Gold won the 1970s and the 2000s, and measured from the end of 1999 it is still ahead: 10.2% against 8.1% a year.

Gold vs the S&P 500 in one line: stocks have been the better long-term grower, mainly because companies pay dividends and gold pays nothing; gold has been the better shelter in some stock-market crashes and in the inflation of the 1970s, with long, deep falls of its own.

This guide compares the two over almost 59 years: return over many windows, decade by decade, after inflation, volatility, Sharpe ratio, the worst falls and the time underwater, how closely they move together, and what gold did in every large fall of the S&P 500.

Gold vs S&P 500 in numbers

Start (to 13 Nov 2026)S&P 500Gold
Jan 1968 (59 years)10.6%8.3%
Aug 1971 (end of the gold window)11.0%8.5%
Nov 1976 (50 years)11.7%7.0%
Nov 1996 (30 years)9.9%8.0%
Nov 2001 (25 years)9.8%11.1%
Dec 1999 (since 2000)8.1%10.2%
Nov 2006 (20 years)10.8%9.6%
Nov 2016 (10 years)15.1%12.3%
Nov 2021 (5 years)11.5%15.8%
Nov 2023 (3 years)21.0%25.8%
Nov 2025 (1 year)+13.3%−7.4%

Return per year, buy and hold, no costs or taxes. S&P 500 with dividends reinvested; gold in US$ per ounce. Gold before 1987 is the monthly average price, so the first three rows are measured month to month; from 1987 on, daily closes.

Three things stand out:

  • The S&P 500 led over most long windows, but the start date matters. It was ahead from 1968, 1971, 1976 and over 30, 20 and 10 years. Gold was ahead from 2000 and over 25, 5 and 3 years.
  • Dividends decide the long race. Without dividends the S&P 500 index rose 7.8% a year from 1968, a little less than gold's 8.3%. The reinvested dividends added almost 3 percentage points a year.
  • 2026 has gone the other way. Gold reached a record on 29 January 2026 and was 26.9% below it on 13 November; the S&P 500 was 3.3% below its October record and up 11.3% for the year.
Gold vs the S&P 500 since 2004 (growth of 100, log scale)
Growth of 100, buy & hold, total return, log scale. Data to Jul 2026.

The chart uses the market data of the Research Terminal: the S&P 500 through the SPY fund and gold through the GLD fund, which started trading in November 2004.

$10,000 in gold vs $10,000 in the S&P 500

StartS&P 500Gold
Jan 1968$3.75 million$1.08 million
Nov 1976 (50 years)$2.51 million$299,000
Nov 1996 (30 years)$172,000$101,000
Dec 1999$81,900$135,000
Nov 2016 (10 years)$40,700$31,800
Nov 2021 (5 years)$17,200$20,800
Nov 2025 (1 year)$11,300$9,300

Value on 13 November 2026, buy and hold, no costs or taxes; S&P 500 with dividends reinvested.

A gap of two percentage points a year becomes a large gap in money over decades: from 1968, $10,000 in the S&P 500 grew to about 3.5 times as much as $10,000 in gold. From the end of 1999 the order was reversed, because that start came near a stock-market peak and near a low for gold.

Gold vs the S&P 500, decade by decade

DecadeS&P 500GoldS&P 500 after inflationGold after inflationUS inflation
1970s5.7%29.2%−1.6%20.4%7.4%
1980s16.9%−1.2%11.3%−6.0%5.1%
1990s18.0%−3.3%14.6%−6.1%2.9%
2000s−1.0%14.3%−3.5%11.5%2.5%
2010s13.4%3.3%11.5%1.5%1.8%
2020s (to Nov 2026)14.6%14.5%10.2%10.1%4.0%

Return per year from the end of the previous decade (for example, December 1969 to December 1979). Inflation: US consumer prices (CPI). Gold before 1987: monthly average prices.

The table explains why the question has no single answer. Gold won two decades by a wide margin, the S&P 500 won three, and the 2020s so far are a dead heat: 14.6% against 14.5% a year. The winner of one decade often lost the next: gold's best decade, the 1970s, was followed by two decades of losses, and the S&P 500's worst decade, the 2000s, came straight after its best.

Gold vs the S&P 500: calendar-year returns
Calendar-year total returns, buy & hold (last year to date)

Counted by calendar year, from 1969 to 2026, gold beat the S&P 500 in 26 of 58 years. Gold had 24 losing years, the S&P 500 12.

When gold won: the 1970s and the 2000s

The 1970s. Until 1971 foreign governments could exchange their dollars for gold at a fixed $35 an ounce. On 15 August 1971 President Nixon closed that "gold window" (Federal Reserve History), and the price was left to the market. What followed was the period the Federal Reserve calls the Great Inflation, from 1965 to 1982, with inflation above 14% in 1980 (Federal Reserve History). In our data gold went from $35 an ounce in December 1969 to $455 in December 1979, a rise of about 1,200%, and its monthly average reached $675 in January 1980. The S&P 500 returned 73% in total over the decade, dividends included, and lost buying power after inflation.

The decade's turn was as sharp. Paul Volcker took office as Fed chair in August 1979 and fought inflation with higher interest rates; by the end of the 1981–82 recession inflation was back under 5% (Federal Reserve History). From January 1980 to August 1999 gold fell 62%, while the S&P 500 rose more than twentyfold.

The 2000s. From December 1999 to December 2009 the S&P 500 lost 9.8% in total, dividends included, with two falls of 47% and 55% on the way. Gold rose from $288 to $1,095 an ounce, about 281%. The decade shows what a starting point can do: after the strong 1990s, stocks began the decade high and gold began it low.

Volatility and return for the risk

Volatility per year1970s1987–19992000s2010s2020–20262026 to Nov
S&P 50015.9%16.3%22.2%14.8%20.2%14.0%
Gold21.3%13.5%19.0%15.8%19.2%29.2%

From daily returns from 1987; the 1970s from monthly returns (gold has only monthly average prices before 1987).

Their swings have been closer than many expect. Since 1987 gold's daily volatility was 16.7% a year against 18.3% for the S&P 500. Gold swung harder in the 1970s and is swinging far harder in 2026, at about twice the S&P 500's volatility. On monthly returns since 1968, gold's worst month was −18.0% (October 2008) and its best +48.4% (January 1980); for the S&P 500 −21.6% (October 1987) and +16.8% (October 1974).

Sharpe ratioS&P 500Gold
Since 1968 (monthly)0.450.28
Last 10 years0.730.62
Last 5 years0.500.66
Last 3 years1.050.96

Sharpe ratio: average return above 3-month US Treasury bills, divided by volatility. 10, 5 and 3 years on daily data.

Over the whole period the S&P 500 paid more return for each unit of risk. Gold had the better ratio over the last five years. Our guide on the Sharpe ratio explains how to read it.

Worst falls and time underwater

Gold below its previous high since 1968: the five deepest falls shaded
Fall from the previous all-time high, monthly low; shaded: the five deepest falls, from the peak until the old high was back. Gold in US$ per ounce: monthly average prices 1968–1986, daily closes from 1987 to Nov 2026.
PeakLowFallBack at the old high
S&P 500
Nov 1968May 1970−32.9%Mar 1971
Jan 1973Oct 1974−45.1%Jul 1976
Aug 1987Oct 1987−33.0%Jun 1989
Mar 2000Oct 2002−47.4%Oct 2006
Oct 2007Mar 2009−55.2%Aug 2012
Feb 2020Mar 2020−33.8%Aug 2020
Gold
Dec 1974Aug 1976−40.2%Mar 1978
Jan 1980Aug 1999−62.6%May 2006
Mar 2008Nov 2008−29.7%Sep 2009
Aug 2011Dec 2015−44.4%Jul 2020
Jan 2026Nov 2026−26.9%not yet

S&P 500 with dividends, every fall of more than 30% since 1968; gold, every fall of more than 25%. Gold before 1987 on monthly average prices: measured from the record of $850 set on 21 January 1980, gold was back above it only on 2 January 2008, almost 28 years later (Dawn/AFP).

The S&P 500 had the deepest single fall since 1968, −55.2% in 2007–09, but it was back at its old high within seven years every time. Gold's falls were slower and far longer. After its 1980 peak it stayed below the old high for 26 years on monthly prices, and after inflation for almost 45 years, until October 2024. Since 1968 gold spent 57% of all months more than 20% below its previous high; the S&P 500 13%.

After inflation the S&P 500's longest wait was 13 years: its real value fell 58.4% from March 2000 to March 2009 and was back only in May 2013. Our guides on max drawdown and on stock market crashes in history look at these falls in more depth.

Are gold and the S&P 500 correlated?

Barely. The correlation of their monthly returns from 1968 to 2026 was −0.01, where 1 means always moving together, 0 no link and −1 always in opposite directions. On daily returns since 1987 it was −0.03.

Correlation of monthly returns1970s1980s1990s2000s2010s2020s
Gold with the S&P 500−0.130.05−0.140.040.020.17
Gold vs the S&P 500: 36-month correlation of monthly returns
Below 0: the two move in opposite directions (the hedge works) · above 0: they move together · monthly total returns

Over rolling 36-month windows since 1968 the correlation ranged from −0.47 (September 1990) to +0.44 (August 2014), and was below zero 55% of the time. It has drifted up in the 2020s: on daily returns over the twelve months to 13 November 2026 it was 0.30, higher than in any decade in the table.

What gold did in stock-market crashes

S&P 500 fall, peak to lowS&P 500Gold
Nov 1968 – May 1970−32.9%−10.0%
Jan 1973 – Oct 1974−45.1%+137.5%
Nov 1980 – Aug 1982−20.3%−45.8%
Aug – Oct 1987−33.0%+5.4%
Jul – Oct 1990−19.2%+7.3%
Jul – Aug 1998−19.1%−6.6%
Mar 2000 – Oct 2002−47.4%+12.3%
Oct 2007 – Mar 2009−55.2%+24.5%
Sep – Dec 2018−19.4%+5.1%
Feb – Mar 2020−33.8%−2.5%
Jan – Oct 2022−24.5%−6.8%

Every S&P 500 fall of 19% or more since 1968, with dividends; gold over the same days. Gold before 1987 on monthly average prices.

In 11 large S&P 500 falls since 1968, gold rose in 6 and fell in 5. It did best in the long bear markets of 1973–74, 2000–02 and 2007–09. In the fastest falls it often went down at first: in the Covid crash of 2020 it lost 2.5%, and in 2008 it fell 29.7% from March to November before recovering. The one case where gold fell much more than stocks was 1980–82, in the first years of gold's long fall from its 1980 peak.

By calendar year the picture is similar: the S&P 500 fell in 12 years since 1969, and gold rose in 6 of them, including +67.2% in 1973, +72.0% in 1974 and +24.7% in 2002. Our guides on protecting a portfolio from a crash and gold vs bonds compare gold with other hedges.

Gold vs the S&P 500 and inflation

Over the whole period both beat inflation, which averaged 4.0% a year: the S&P 500 by 6.4% and gold by 4.1% a year. The year-by-year record shows where gold earned its reputation.

Calendar years since 1969YearsS&P 500, median yearGold, median year
US inflation above 5%13−3.2%+5.7%
US inflation 3% or less27+15.8%+8.5%

In the 13 years with inflation above 5%, gold beat inflation in 7 and the S&P 500 in 4. Most of those years were in the 1970s. The 2021–22 inflation was different: gold returned −3.5% and −0.1% while prices rose 7.0% and 6.5%. Over ten-year periods gold lost buying power more often: in 40% of all rolling ten-year windows since 1968, against 14% for the S&P 500. Gold's worst ten years after inflation, October 1980 to October 1990, lost 9.6% a year.

Which one won over 10 and 20 years?

Measured over every rolling ten-year window since 1968, at each month-end, the S&P 500 was ahead in 68% and gold in 32%. Over twenty-year windows the S&P 500 led in 73%. Gold's largest ten-year lead was February 1970 to February 1980 (34.2% against 6.5% a year); the S&P 500's was September 1990 to September 2000 (19.2% against −3.8%).

Return per year over the previous 10 years: S&P 500 vs gold
Return per year over the previous 10 years, at every month-end, buy & hold with dividends

The S&P 500 priced in gold

Another way to compare them is to ask how many ounces of gold the S&P 500 index buys (price index, without dividends):

  • January 1968: 2.6 ounces
  • January 1980: 0.17 ounces, the low (on monthly average gold prices)
  • August 2000: 5.5 ounces, the high
  • August 2011: 0.67 ounces
  • December 2021: 2.6 ounces
  • 13 November 2026: 1.9 ounces

The ratio swings in long waves: up when stocks lead for years, down when gold does. Its median since 1968 was about 1.6 ounces.

Gold and the S&P 500 together

Because their returns have been almost unrelated, adding gold to stocks changed the risk of the mix more than its return. The table shows a backtest of mixes from December 1971, rebalanced every month.

Gold shareReturn per yearVolatilityWorst fall
0% (S&P 500 only)10.9%15.2%−51.0%
10%11.0%13.8%−46.0%
20%11.0%12.7%−40.6%
30%10.9%12.0%−34.8%
50%10.5%12.1%−33.8%
100% (gold only)8.5%18.9%−62.1%

Hypothetical backtest, Dec 1971 – Nov 2026: month-end prices (gold before 1987: monthly averages), S&P 500 with dividends, rebalanced monthly, no costs or taxes. Month-end values miss falls within a month.

80% S&P 500 and 20% gold vs the S&P 500 alone (rebalanced monthly)
Growth of 100, log scale · total return, rebalanced monthly, no costs or taxes · data from 2004-11

Up to about 30% gold, the mix returned about the same as stocks alone in this period, with lower swings and a smaller worst fall. This rests on a history in which gold's best and worst decades fell at different times from those of stocks; it is a description of the past, not a rule. Our guide on the 60/40 portfolio covers mixes of stocks and bonds.

Gold vs the S&P 500: what is the difference?

  • What you own. The S&P 500 is a share in the earnings of large US companies, which pay part of them out as dividends. Gold is a metal that pays no income; its return comes only from the price.
  • Where the long-run return comes from. For the S&P 500, earnings growth plus dividends: without dividends its return since 1968 drops from 10.6% to 7.8% a year. For gold, changes in what buyers will pay for it, which have moved with inflation, interest rates and fear.
  • How long the bad times last. The S&P 500's falls were deeper at times but shorter; gold's could last a generation.
  • Access. Both can be held through funds: SPY has tracked the S&P 500 since 1993 and GLD gold since 2004.

For gold next to other assets, see silver vs gold and Bitcoin vs gold; for the S&P 500 on its own, S&P 500 historical returns. For the S&P 500 against bonds, Bitcoin and the Dow, see stocks vs bonds, Bitcoin vs S&P 500 and S&P 500 vs Dow Jones.

The short answer

On data from January 1968 to 13 November 2026, the S&P 500 with dividends returned 10.6% a year and gold 8.3%, and the S&P 500 led in about two thirds of all ten-year periods. Gold won the 1970s and the 2000s, is ahead since 2000 (10.2% against 8.1% a year), and rose in 6 of the 11 large stock-market falls since 1968. Its own falls were the longest: 26 years below the 1980 high, almost 45 after inflation. Their returns have been almost unrelated (correlation −0.01), which is why many portfolios hold some of both rather than choosing one.

Gold and the S&P 500 are both among the six core markets of the free Research Terminal: their falls from the high, updated daily, in the Drawdowns tab, and how they move against each other right now in the Correlations tab.

Educational research, not investment advice. Past returns do not guarantee future results. Backtests are hypothetical.

Frequently asked questions

Has gold outperformed the S&P 500?

Over the long run, no: from January 1968 to November 2026 the S&P 500 with dividends returned 10.6% a year and gold 8.3%. But gold was ahead over some periods: since the end of 1999 (10.2% against 8.1% a year), over 25, 5 and 3 years, and in the 1970s and 2000s. Past returns do not guarantee future results.

Gold vs S&P 500 over the last 10 years?

From November 2016 to November 2026 the S&P 500 with dividends returned 15.1% a year and gold 12.3%: $10,000 grew to about $40,700 and $31,800. Over the last five years gold was ahead, 15.8% against 11.5% a year.

Gold vs S&P 500 over the last 20 years?

From November 2006 to November 2026 the S&P 500 with dividends returned 10.8% a year and gold 9.6%: $10,000 grew to about $78,300 and $62,300. Over 25 years, from November 2001, gold was ahead: 11.1% against 9.8% a year.

Did gold beat the S&P 500 since 1971?

No. From August 1971, when the US stopped exchanging dollars for gold at $35 an ounce, to November 2026 the S&P 500 with dividends returned 11.0% a year and gold 8.5%. Without dividends the S&P 500 index returned 8.2% a year, slightly less than gold.

Is gold a good hedge against a stock market crash?

Sometimes. In the 11 S&P 500 falls of 19% or more since 1968, gold rose in 6, by up to 137.5% in 1973–74, and fell in 5, by 45.8% in 1980–82. In fast crashes such as March 2020 it often fell at first. Educational information, not a recommendation.

Are gold and the S&P 500 correlated?

Hardly. The correlation of their monthly returns was −0.01 from 1968 to 2026, and over rolling three-year windows it moved between −0.47 and +0.44. In the twelve months to November 2026 the daily correlation was 0.30, higher than in any earlier decade.

Which is better against inflation, gold or stocks?

In years of high inflation, gold: in the 13 years since 1969 with US inflation above 5%, gold had a median return of +5.7% and the S&P 500 −3.2%. Over long periods stocks beat inflation by more, 6.4% against 4.1% a year since 1968, and gold lost buying power in 40% of all ten-year periods.

What was the worst fall of gold and of the S&P 500?

The S&P 500 with dividends fell 55.2% from October 2007 to March 2009 and was back at its high in August 2012. Gold fell 62.6% from January 1980 to August 1999 (monthly average prices) and stayed below its 1980 high for 26 years, almost 45 years after inflation.

Should I invest in gold or the S&P 500?

No guide can answer that for you; it depends on what the holding is meant to do and how long a fall you can sit through. The record shows the trade-off: more long-run growth and dividends from the S&P 500, a different pattern and some crash protection from gold, with very long falls of its own. Educational information, not a recommendation.

Cite or link this guide

Writing about this topic? You are welcome to quote the figures with a link to this page. Click a box to copy.

Citation (APA)

Hamann, H. (2026). Gold vs S&P 500: returns since 1968, decade by decade. InvestWealth.com. https://www.investwealth.com/learn/guides/gold-vs-sp500

Link (HTML)

<a href="https://www.investwealth.com/learn/guides/gold-vs-sp500">Gold vs S&P 500: returns since 1968, decade by decade</a> (InvestWealth.com)
Free Research Terminal

Gold and the S&P 500 side by side, in live numbers

  • Strategies: gold with a rule-based strategy against buy & hold, with equity curve, Sharpe ratio and worst fall
  • Drawdowns: the four deepest falls of gold and the days each took to recover
  • Momentum, seasonality and correlations for gold and five more core markets
Free · no card · instant access · login details by email
Or run the free Portfolio Crash Test →

Related guides

Educational research, not investment advice. Disclaimer.